More disobedience recently

Maybe its my imagination but I have found Gemini to be more “disobedient” recently (last week or so). 2.5 Pro will often try and make many additional and “bad” changes to my files alongside the intended change. Many of the changes it tries to do are very odd because they don’t seem to have any real reason to them.

No matter how many times I specify a “surgical” or precise change of only one feature and that nothing else in the code should be changed… Gemini will confirm its only going to make that one precise change, then try and make a load of unrelated changes at the same time and then be convinced that it only made the one precise change I asked for.

Today I asked for a simple change to make a field on a form read only which would have required changing a single line of code and Gemini proposed massive changes to the file including randomly deleting options out of other drop down lists, modifying my hardcoded authentication that is there for test purposes and deleting a bunch of other unrelated code.

I don’t remember having this level of issue with the ability to make small targeted changes before.

4 Likes

Same here. airules.md file routinely ignored by Pro 2.5 as instructions in the prompts.

Same here. No matter how many times I remind it of airules or gemini.md it disobeys them.

Yes i noticed that too, i second this.

Lamentablemente cierto.

El Prototyper literalmente enloqució. Tenía mi app en un estado practicamente óptimo y en pleno trabajo empezó a cambiar todo, paleta de colores, agregado de componentes, cambió la interfaz y retrocedí mas de un mes, la app en realidad perdío todo ya que ni siquiera puedo hacer un simple login.

Desde el día 16/07 o 17/07 pasados que esto ocurrió (en el panel de Estado de Estudio Firebase dice que el incidente comenzó antes) que NO he podido recuperarr nada. Una gran perdida de tiempo.

Una pista para seguir… a partir del incidente, y al arrancar la app, en la consola aparece un mensaje de integración de Vercel… y esto NO estaba antes.

Quizá al integral al Prototyper, se perdió toda línea de trabajo con los workspaces (según veo somos muchos los que tenemos problemas ahora)